Google+

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

The Untouchables

The Don of the Canadian #ChickenMafia (ie. Chicken Farmers of Canada) has now been ruled to be "untouchable". They answer not to the Canadian public.

Robert Stack, playing the role of Eliot Ness, who
sought to clean up the Mob ("The Untouchables")
from Chicago Ill. in the 1930's
The only supervision and restraint that limits CFC's actions is the Farm Product Council of Canada ("FPCC"), which administers the Farm Products Agencies Act.

You can read it and weep yourselves here:  FPCC letter & decision of 2013/12/17

The questions Small Flockers asked were for objective evidence that CFC was compliant with the Act and the Federal-Provincial Agreement on Chicken 2001.

Since there is no transparency and no accountability, CFC is able to continue doing as it pleases.

What are the chances of success in asking the FPCC to show that they have adequately supervised and monitored CFC's actions, like they are responsible for doing?

Is there any hope in a Judicial Review of FPCC's decision?

Just how big of a detour must be made around this bureaucratic cesspool for the #ChickenMafia, their henchmen, and Supply Management in Canada?

I have sent the following email to FPCC today:

I acknowledge receipt of the FPCC's decision of Dec. 17, 2013 that the Chicken Farmers of Canada ("CFC") have no duty to answer questions or inquiries posed by the public.
I therefore request copies of all documents from Jan. 1, 2012 to today that clearly demonstrate (using unbiased, third party, independent, and objective data that is in FPCC's care or control) that shows that CFC is fully compliant with:
  1. the Farm Product Agencies Act,
  2. the Federal-Provincial Agreement Chicken 2001, and
  3. all mandatory directives of FPCC.
  4. CFC is operating in an efficient, effective, manner
  5. CFC is achieving the intended results on a consistent basis
FPCC is supposed to monitor CFC and report to government.  I wonder what data they have collected, and what they have reported, if anything.

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Small Flocker Price Difference

Are Small Flockers just as bad or worse than the #ChickenMafia for gouging the public on sky-high prices?

Many who buy farm gate chicken state that Small Flockers charge more than retail, and are always sold out.

The non-TRQ tariff seems to be the main controlling and enabling factor for all prices of chicken in Canada.  The second factor is the inflated chicken feed prices, which the quota-bearing chicken farmers allowed and/or encouraged to increase 33.3% above comparable market prices for similar feeds.

Why would farmers do that when they would have to pay those higher prices?  That's easy to explain.  Every time the feed mills raised the chicken feed prices, the chicken farmers who bought that feed made additional profit.   , as the quota-boys received extra profits for themselves every time the feed mill raised prices (due to CFO's bogus inflated FCR, which they were ordered to reduce by 16.3% in Aug. 2013). Inflated feed prices cause inflated farm gate live chicken prices, inflated wholesale, and inflated retail prices.  Since each step uses a % markup, the penalty to consumers increases as the chicken passes through each step along the way, so the 33.3% premium for chicken feed becomes a 19.98% premium for live chicken, a 67.97% premium for eviscerated chicken at wholesale, and a 235.16% premium at retail grocery store meat counters.  See http://canadiansmallflockers.blogspot.ca/2013/05/chicken-feed-price-conspiracy.html

As a small flocker, I currently pay $18 per 25 kg bag, which is $720 per metric tonne of feed.  I believe the Supply Management quota-owning factory chicken operation currently pays around $388.375 per tonne (quota period A-121), which means small flockers pay 85.4% more for their feed.  Assuming feed costs are 60% of the total costs, and the other 40% of costs are similar for both small flockers and quota-boys, then small flocker farm gate chicken meat prices should be 11.23% higher than the factory farm prices (1.854 * 0.6= 1.1123 or 11.23% premium).

Now that the bogus FCR has been ordered to be fixed, there is neither a negative nor positive effect on the chicken factory farmer when a feed mill raises their prices, as the farmer automatically gets 100% reimbursed for all feed price changes, whether an increase or decrease.  Since the feed mills have over 10 years of bad habits for rapid price increases above market rates, why would they change their ways now?  Who will object when the feed mills raise their prices again and again?

What this means is that feed prices will continue to inflate, and import tariffs will continue to enable 200% to 300% over-charging for chicken, or worse.

Who pay for all these #ChickenMafia excesses and price gouging?

It's the Canadian consumer who pays.

That's the reason chicken price abuse will continue until the Canadian consumer revolts, or the government reins in the Supply Management system.

Friday, December 13, 2013

TV Interview Opportunities for Small Flockers

Rebecca Thompson, Sun News Network
Ms. Rebecca Thompson, Sun News Network correspondent did a TV interview of  me today at their offices in Toronto.

Rebecca would like to get some video footage at a small flock poultry farm to add to the story, and interview the farmer on-camera.

Since I am 14 hrs round trip from the Toronto, it isn't practical for Sun News Network to do the interview at my small flock farm. 

The small flock farmer needs to be in or near Toronto.  Rebecca will be in Ottawa next week, then Windsor in early January, so those locations, or some place near Hwy. 401 along the way could be possible too.

You will need to go on the record, and/or will be recognized on TV.  Realize that this will expose you, front and centre to the #ChickenMafia , the Chicken Police, and other authorities.  There is some small but significant risk of revenge, or abuse of power against you by these authorities down the road.  After all, you will be speaking out against the #ChickenMafia

If you are considering this opportunity to help the Small Flockers' cause, or have some questions about how this video interview would work, or would be willing to do the interview under some other terms & conditions, you can anonymously call me or email me so we can discuss it.

Alternatively, you can speak directly with Rebecca.  Here is her contact info:

REBECCA THOMPSON 
Sun News Network Contributor
t 416.601.0010 x5832 | c 647.282.6171 | rebecca.thompson@sunmedia.ca 
25 Ontario Street, Toronto, ON M5A 4L6 
www.sunnewsnetwork.ca | follow me on twitter: @RThompsonSun
 
Sun News Network is Canada’s home for Hard News and Straight Talk. A Quebecor Media company. 
I believe this is a golden opportunity for Small Flockers, and the TV story will be significantly improved by a Small Flocker stepping up to do the interview.

I therefore encourage you to step forward to help our cause.

Inspiration from Mandella

Nelson Mandella
(1918 - 2013)
"The time comes in the life of any nation when there remain only two choices - submit or fight. That time has now come to South Africa. We shall not submit and we have no choice but to hit back by all means in our power in defense of our people, our future, and our freedom."

Nelson Mandella (1918 - 2013), speaking from the prisoner's dock during his trial for terrorism in 1964 at Rivonia, South Africa.

Mandella was subsequently convicted and jailed for 27 years, then released in Feb. 1990, Mandella was elected S. African President in 1994, chose to limit himself to serving just 1 term, stepping down in 1999.

Small Flockers have great inspiration before us, if we choose to follow his footsteps.  Our prayers are to humbly try to fill his shoes, and honor his accomplishments by doing likewise for the oppression, tyranny and civil rights abuses inflicted by the Supply Management Mafia against Small Flockers and all others in Canada.

While the tragedies suffered by Small Flockers and other Canadians at the hands of the Supply Management Mafia are mild compared to the centuries of suffering experienced by black S. Africans, it is still unjust and stings the same.

Thursday, December 12, 2013

#ChickenMafia Bedtime Story

Once upon a time, there was a lion, a zebra, and a vast plain of beautiful, lush grass.  The lion soon saw himself as the most powerful, and unilaterally claimed the title "King of the Beasts".  The zebra heard the lions proclamation, ignored it, and continued to eat the lush green grass.

The zebra fully understood the power of the lion's jaws and claws.  The zebra also had powerful jaws.  In addition, the zebra had a prehensile tongue that grabbed the lush green grass, and ripped off one mouthful after another.

The grass was no match for the strength of the zebra's teeth and tongue.

The lush green, nutritious grass helped the zebra grow strong and run fast.  The faster the zebra was able to run, the safer the zebra felt from the potential attack of the lion.

The beasts dropped their dung here, there, and everywhere on the grassy plain, fertilizing the grass.  The gentle rains came and watered the grass.

The grass grew plentifully, but some grasses were superior to others.  The zebra soon learned where the best grasses grew, and spent the majority of his time in those regions with better grass. The location of the zebras affected the location of the lions.   The better grass received a better share of dung of both zebra and lion.  The better grasses were thereby better fertilized, growing faster and better.

Eating the better grass, the zebra grew strong and multiplied.

The lion, in turn, chased and captured the slowest and weakest of the zebra, ensuring that the zebras with personal shortcomings were not propagated forward to the next generation.  The lion was fortified by the nutritious zebra meat, and the lion multiplied as well.  The weak and slow lions were not successful zebra hunters, were unable to have or support offspring, thereby ensuring that their weaknesses were not passed forward to the next generation.

An ecologically balanced world had formed, and all was good.

One day, the lion tried thinking a little too much.  The lion thought, that since he was the King of the Beasts, he was the most important part of the world, far more important than the zebra, and certainly more important than the grass which was walked on by both lions and zebras.

The lions called a meeting, and suggested to the zebras that what the world needed was more lions, and better fed lions.  If this was done, everybody would benefit, said the lions.

"How would the zebras benefit from more lions, and better fed lions?", asked the zebras.

The lions told the zebras that more lions would ensure that the zebras got lots of exercise running for their lives from the lions, and therefore the zebras would be fitter and healthier, and their offspring would improve that much faster.

The zebras weren't totally convinced by the lion's proposal.

One zebra spoke up, saying, "I think we need more zebras, not more lions.  I think we need more and better grass for the zebras to eat".

The lions started to laugh at what they thought was a silly zebra idea.

Nobody asked the grass what they thought.  Nobody asked the dung for their opinion.  Nobody thought to ask the rains for their ideas.  The grass was upset about being ignored.  The grass decided to show its sorrow by actions rather than words.

The grass held back its seeds, so new grass did not grow.  The grass grew very strong roots and stored its energy below ground.  The green shoots withered in the hot sun, and turned to dry, inedible, tasteless straw.

The zebras had a very difficult time finding enough food for themselves, so they migrated to far away, strange lands.  The lions were left alone with a dry dusty plain, with no zebras to eat.

The lions soon learned that all aspects of the circle of life were equally important.  The King of the Beasts isn't much of a king without his subjects, or without food for his subjects.

The lions apologized to the grass. The lions fertilized the grass. The rains came again, and the grass could no longer contain its vigor.  The grass grew lush and green again.  The zebra smelled the lush green grass from far away, and had soon returned.

This time, the rain, grass, dung, zebras, and lions lived as equals in harmony.  They realized that each was an important part of an eco-systemic feedback loop that worked through their mutual synergy.  No longer did one try to take advantage of the other.

The End

*   *   *

What is the moral of the story for #ChickenMafia?

I would suggest that things have gotten way out of balance.  It is more grass that can produce more zebras, which in turn permits more lions.  It is the small who permit the mighty.

#ChickenMafia rule as if they have the divine right of kings. There is little or no need to improve, for both the lousy and the excellent get the same minimum price, and have guaranteed customers.  Customers cannot choose their suppliers.  Over time, the #ChickenMafia have naturally grown fat and sloppy due to the dysfunctional system in which they live and benefit.

The #ChickenMafia's insists on recklessly gaining greater and greater wealth for themselves, to persecute the Small Flockers, and oppress and starve the citizens through 300% higher prices for chicken.  It is these things that has placed our chicken eco-system akilter, and dysfunctional.

It is time to re-balance the chicken lifecycle systems in our society.

The #ChickenMafia does not create wealth, nor feed the people. The #ChickenMafia creates a little wealth for a few who demand additional status and privilege, but in doing so, it destroys far greater wealth and rights of everybody else; a net negative to society.  The #ChickenMafia destroys our health with bogus chicken meat that is dangerous, toxic, disease-causing, and not sufficiently nutritious.

It is time to re-balance our chicken systems.

The following is a 6 minute TED talk by Mr. Nick Hanauer, a venture capitalist who was one of the first non-family investors in Amazon.com , a billionaire, and has a passion for exposing an invalid assumption in our society, similar to the #ChickenMafia 's assumption about their status and privilege.

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

First Heinz, now Kellogg's, Who's Next?

Heinz's closure will take away 740 direct, and possibly another 500 indirect jobs.  Kellogg's closure is 500 direct jobs, and likely another 500 indirect jobs; for a grand total of 2,240 jobs leaving Ontario's agri-foods sector.

Premier & Ag Minister Wynne announced a few months ago that she wants a doubling of agri-food exports before 2020.  Now that Heinz and Kellogg's are leaving us, she is miles behind the starting point she had a few months ago.

Whatever will she do?  Here is a suggestion:

As posted on this Blog on Mar. 13, 2013 Why Not Export Canadian Chicken? Canada’s #ChickenMafia has only 1.4% market share of exported chicken for OECD nations; a mere insignificant blip.  Canada is in last place, last out of the 7 OECD nations for chicken exports.

Canada is an exporting nation.  Canada could export chicken too.  Theoretically, Canada could, if we worked hard, gain up to 50% market share for OECD exported chicken.  It would take a while to achieve, but if we did this, Canada would need to grow 5 times more chicken than what we do today.  That means 5 times more jobs, 5 times bigger markets for Canada’s grains, 5 times the spin-offs for feed mills, farm machinery, etc.

Chicken Farmers of Ontario (“CFO”) recently announced that Ontario’s #ChickenMafia produce $2.7 Billion per year of economic activity in Ontario.  Since Ontario is about 1/3 of all chicken in Canada, we can project that all of Canada has $8.1 Billion of #ChickenMafia impact.  Taking this to 5 times current activity for OECD chicken exports, that’s $40.5 Billion for Canada, and Ontario’s share would be 1/3 of that, which would be $13.5 Billion.

Would Premier Wynne be happy to get an additional $10.8 Billion per year (13.5 – 2.7= 10.8) of economic activity and exports for Ontario’s agri-foods sector?

I think so.

There’s only one problem:   Supply Management for chicken.

Right now, the #ChickenMafia have 99.97% market share for chicken in Canada, at a price which is 300% higher than the world price, thanks to their Supply Management monopoly.  The #ChickenMafia prefer to suck the blood of Canadians at 300% price gouging, rather than the challenges of exporting chicken onto the world market.

If others could get a sweetheart deal like the #ChickenMafia monopoly, they’d likely do the same, so let's not be too quick to blame the #ChickenMafia.  It was the government who freely gave them, and continues to support them with this monopoly.

Perhaps we can encourage the #ChickenMafia to come out of their shell, spread their wings, and compete on the international chicken markets, if not for themselves, then as their patriotic duty to help their fellow Canadians [pause until laughter subsides, then continue].

There is just one problem.  Nobody else in the world is stupid enough, if given a choice, to pay 300% more for their chicken.  Therefore, it's a non-starter for Canada's #ChickenMafia to try exporting chicken at Canadian domestic prices.  If the #ChickenMafia wants to export chicken, it will have to be at the world price for chicken.

With WTO (World Trade Organization) rules, #ChickenMafia can’t export chicken for sale at world prices, because that is the definition of “dumping” (ie. selling internationally at prices lower than domestic prices).  As soon as Canada’s #ChickenMafia started exporting at world chicken prices, and if they were to gain significant market share, they would soon be slapped with dozens of WTO complaints for dumping, and the trade wars begin.

Darn!  Another great idea hits a brick wall.  If only we didn’t have 100% commitment to Supply Management and the price gouging that the #ChickenMafia gets to do to Canadians.  That extra $10.8 Billion per year of agri-exports from Ontario sure looked appealing.

Oh well, there’s always Ontario Works (ie. welfare, government dole).  Let somebody else worry about it.  Let the “Power That Be” come up with a better idea that actually has a hope of being implemented.

What do I know?  I’m just an unemployed bum after decades of working at Heinz or Kellogg’s or elsewhere.

Is it Tribunal Time?

I think it's time to go to the Tribunal for our complaint against Chicken Farmers of Ontario.

It was June 10, 2013 that I posted about our green light to proceed to the Tribunal (see Getting Ready: OMAF Tribunal Appeal).

Small Flockers believe that CFO has been mis-directed, incompetent, negligent, exceeded its authority, acted in bad faith, colluded, in conflict of interest, and deserving of a lump of coal from Santa Claus.

I have been slowly collecting the necessary points for our claims, evidence, and case law.  It is intended that most, if not all, of the 166 postings on this Blog will be included in our filings with the Tribunal as evidence in the appeal.  It is intended for us to request written answers from CFO for all of the issues that we have covered here.  During the hearing, it is assumed that CFO personnel will be available to defend their written answers and reply to all of the issues that we have raised on this Blog.

In Figure 1 is a map of the Supply Management system for chicken in Ontario.  We have used this as one of the tools to help build our case for the Tribunal.  Complicated, eh?  The more complicated it is, the more the eyeballs of citizens glaze over, and the #ChickenMafia is left alone to do as it pleases.  It a very standard ploy in systemic oppression.

Based on this map, I have most areas covered in my investigations and analysis of Supply Management for chicken in Ontario, and the rest of Canada.
Figure 1:  Map of the Supply Management Bureaucracy for Ontario

It should be an interesting Tribunal hearing.  I wonder how far the Commissioners will allow me to proceed?

No matter how they decide, if we are given a fair, just, and impartial hearing, and we get to present all of our evidence, and ask all of our questions, then we have done the best we can.

One thing that we didn't receive was a Whistleblower Insider from the #ChickenMafia.  I would have hoped that one of 1,114 members of the #ChickenMafia might have stepped forward, unable to stomach any more of the wrong-headed nonsense of CFO and Supply Management.

Nobody stepped forward.  What could that mean?

I think this Blog has repeatedly proven that there are significant problems in paradise.

Therefore, I can only assume that all the members of the #ChickenMafia are experiencing one or more of the following:
  1. They are brain dead, as all thinking is done for them by the CFO Board;
  2. Too busy with their selfish endeavors to concern themselves with the consequences they create for others;
  3. Frozen in fear at what would be done to them if they broke rank and became a Whistleblower;
  4. Apathetic and defeated blobs of primordial ooze that has insufficient backbone to oppose anybody, least of all fellow members of the #ChickenMafia, nor the all powerful CFO;
  5. Up to their eyeballs in debt and other consequences, hoping that the whole system hangs together so they can continue to exist, rather than be swept away in the tide of change that they fear may soon arrive.
If a #ChickenMafia Whistleblower wants to step forward with some insider info, we're all ears.  You will be respected for your difficult decision, and your confidentiality will be protected.  Even if you just wanted to talk, or wanted to find out some info about Small Flockers, give us a call, or send us an email.  We have few secrets.  I would enjoy speaking with you.

If there is a lawyer, paralegal, or other talented person who is willing to assist our cause and the Tribunal, now is a great time to step forward.  You can volunteer anything from 15 minutes of your time, money, or suggestions.  We take anything, and will recognize and appreciate everything.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Old McDonald had a Farm

Old McDonald had a Farm.  Not any more. Yes, that's past tense.  That was long ago.  Old McDonald doesn't have that farm any more.  That idyllic, pastoral view of farming is long gone.  Factory farms and quarterly profits for corporations are the reality of today.

Unfortunately, the concept of farming held by most Canadians hasn't changed very much from what they learned at the age of 3 years from the following video and similar simplistic farming propaganda.




That's exactly how the #ChickenMafia wants to keep it, too.  This simplistic view of farming ensures:
  • Happy citizens who stay asleep, and don't ask questions
  • #ChickenMafia aren't bothered by the public and their "silly" questions and expectations;
  • #ChickenMafia can maximize their profit extraction from the citizen's wallets.
Perhaps Canadians are ready for something closer to reality.  In the alternative, small flock poultry farming, for the most part, already meets the public's perceptions and expectations.  Perhaps that is a vote in favor of small flock poultry farming by most Canadians.  Once Canadian are allowed to know the truth about the adulteration and wrong-headed sneaky actions of the #ChickenMafia, they will no longer support factory farming. 

With Canada's growing population, we would expect that the total number of chickens raised in Canada would be increasing over the years.  The census data collected by Statistics Canada and reported in CANSIM Table 004-0004 presenting census data from 1921 to 2011 confirms this perception.

The census data is collected every 5 years, and prior to 1951, only a subset of today's data was collected by StatsCan.  This necessitated our interpolation and projection of the StatsCan data, which was done by SFPFC's hard working statistician (me).
Figure 1

Figure 1 shows that the total number of chickens raised on Canadian farms has been increasing at 1.157% per year, which doubles and re-doubles the number of chickens every 60.5 years.  We now have 288 times more chickens grown in Canada, as compared to 1921.  As of 2011. there are 3.5 chickens for every man, woman, and child in Canada.  We're outnumbered.

Figure 2
Figure 2 shows that the number of farms that raise chickens has been dropping like a stone; decreasing 5.34% per year since 1921, which will cause a halfing and re-halfing of the number of chicken farms every 13.1 years. As of 2011, Canada has just 1.06% of the number of chicken farms that existed in 1921.

This means that 98.94% of Canada's chicken farms have disappeared since 1921; forced out of business by today's #ChickenMafia and its predecessors.

As of 2011, there are only 20,645 farms remaining in Canada that raise chickens.  Of those, there are about 2,700 that are members of the #ChickenMafia; those who own Supply Management quota for chicken.

There are government programs to protect threatened wildlife from extinction.  Why not have similar programs for the threatened extinction of the remaining 1.06% of small flock poultry farmers who are still operating today? 

To claim status as a "farm", you need at least $7,000per year as farm income.  There are people who raise chickens in their suburb backyard.  We estimate there are a total of at least 35,000 small flocks in Canada; possibly more.

Figure 3

Figure 3 shows the average number of chickens per farms that raised chickens.  As can be seen here, the chicken farms have been getting bigger and bigger since 1921, increasing at 6.85% per year, which doubles and re-doubles the average farm's bird population every 10.2 years.

This means that the chicken farms of today have 30,619 times more chickens on the average chicken farm as compared to 1921 farms.  In the previous Blog posting Why are there Gorillas in Ontario's Chicken Coops? I showed how Chicken Farmers of Ontario ("CFO") tried to hide that the largest chicken farms have quota units estimated to be 196,500 which means that about 196,500 birds are on the largest Ontario chicken farm at any point in the year.  That is 9,338 times the number of chickens on the average chicken farm of 1921.

Therefore the largest Ontario chicken farm has an intensification and concentration of the environmental loading, pollution, and impacts that are 9,338 times greater today than the small flock farms of 1921.  No wonder we have the environmental problems that we do today (eg. landfills overflowing with chicken manure, contaminated ground water & drinking water wells, manure run-off into ditches & streams, algae blooms, and dead or dying lakes from excess nitrogen and/or phosphorous which causes oxygen depletion and dead fish).

Other data has shown that the statistical distribution of farm size is quite wide and diverse. This means that there are a huge number of farms that keep just a few chickens, plus there are a few farms that keep 200,000 birds. A median value would be more enlightening, but this median data isn't available.

The impact of average vs. median statistics might be explained by a typical Tim Horton's coffee shop.  On a typical day, the median and average income of the customers in a Tim Horton's will be pretty much the same number.  If the billionaire Bill Gates, founder of Microsoft, walks in the front door of that Tim Horton's, and we were to re-calculate the median and average incomes, we would find that the median value had hardly changed, but the average income level had dramatically increased due to one person entering the Tim Horton's.  That's why median values are often better, more representative of diverse populations.

What does all this mean?  It means that the family chicken farm that used to be near your community has disappeared.  As Blogged previously (Buried Alive in Chicken Manure), the animal waste from chicken farms has been concentrated and intensified to the point of:
  • Overwhelming the poultry farm workers with significant health and safety risks from excess exposure to ammonia, hydrogen sulphide and other toxic gases, dust, residues from antibiotics and other drugs fed to the chickens, and other issues.
  • Overwhelming the farm's ability to cope with the inputs, nutrient management issues, waste disposal, vermin and other pests, shipments, road wear and spreading contamination from farm traffic, and other issues;
  • Overwhelming the local and regional environment with the soil, air, and water pollution that occurs.
  • Loss of local jobs, economic spin-offs, and prosperity
  • Loss of locally produced, affordable, safe, sustainable, environmentally friendly food production
What would Canada be like if all government jobs only existed in Ottawa, and that is where all decisions were made?  How well do you think you'd be served by that type of government?  There were specific reasons that the Federal Government has done de-centralization of the civil service.

Of course, all or most of these problems can be avoided, or are far easier to manage, or mitigate with small flock poultry farming.

Perhaps the #ChickenMafia needs to loosen the reins, or somebody takes the reins away from them for mis-management and bad faith.