Google+
Showing posts with label assumptions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label assumptions. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Agricultural Myth Busting

CFIB (Canadian Federation of Independent Business) has attempted to bust 4 "myths" with its recent survey of CFIB members who are in the agriculture sector with their 2014 State of Canadian Agriculture Survey.  Did they achieve their purpose?

CFIB states that the public (and possibly many farmers) have the strong impression of problems in agriculture (or significant opportunities, depending on your outlook).

CFIB is upset that there is a general feeling in Canada that:
  • Agriculture is not innovative and modern;
  • The agriculture sector is shrinking.
  • Farming is unsustainable and potentially environmentally harmful.
  • Farming is moving away from family businesses toward corporate operations.
I would agree that many Canadians, if not the majority, hold these impressions.  Even those who are directly working in agriculture, or serve the agriculture industry indirectly, seem to have these concerns.

CFIB offer some survey results to try and bust what CFIB calls these "myths about Canadian agriculture".

CFIB asked some very broad and general questions, which in some ways, lead the survey participants to create a positive spin on the survey results.  In that regard, I can't agree that the survey was well constructed, nor balanced, nor objective.  Obviously, CFIB has conducted this survey for their own purposes, as well as those of the members surveyed.  The survey seems to reinforce CFIB's talking points and lobbying efforts, which is most likely the primary point and purpose of the CFIB survey.

For example, CFIB says that 81% of agri-businesses use the Internet for obtaining "information, products and/or services".  Based on the survey, we don't know whether this Internet access occurs from their own home, or their agri-business offices, or the public library, or their kid's house in the city.  Statistics Canada says that  83% of Canadians have access to Internet in their homes as of 2012.  We therefore conclude that farmers surveyed are at least 2% behind the Canadian average.  This may be within the accuracy of the survey, but certainly is not a ringing endorsement that proves Canada has world-class, tech-savvy ag. businesses.  CFIB appears to have gone way beyond the data by generous assumptions.

Agriculture is a broad area.  I focus here on this Blog on poultry (supply management & small flock), for meat birds and eggs.  I can find one comment in the survey that might be from an egg farmer:
"We invest in leadership training, we pursue new or improved product lines through R&D initiatives, we commissioned surveys into emerging market trends to support our customers’ development of their business. We are building sales into the Omega 3 market but it is very costly relative to short term payback."
The other comments might be from the poultry sector, but it is impossible to tell for sure.  While the above comment sound good, is it proof positive that clearly busts any or all of the alleged myths of agriculture?  I think CFIB has again stretched the survey data way beyond the breaking point.

Perhaps the Supply Management sectors can take this as a challenge, to construct a balanced, unbiased survey of their members, then publish ALL of the results so we can all know for sure.  Obviously, there will be areas that can be improved.  These local boards can then set their strategic plans and publish them in the open.  Everybody (government, members, small flockers, and consumers) can then fully understand the issues, the current status, and plans to improve.

Note that surveys can be constructed so as to make it difficult to impossible to get negative outcomes in the results.  I wouldn't call that a balanced, unbiased survey.  Garbage questions create garbage survey results.

Later, when a follow-up survey is conducted and published the following year, we can see the plan vs. actual, why the shortfalls occurred, and what they are going to do to close those gaps.  On-site audits by independent auditors can be done at random farm survey locations to determine how skewed the true results are, as compared to what the farmer wrote on their survey form.  Then we know what the farmer thinks (or wants others to think), and what is really going on.  That's powerful data!

That is what accountability with the public's money and power is all about.

I forecast that as long as Supply Management is allowed to exist in its current form, there is higher likelihood  of snow blizzards occurring on the Moon.  In other words, it will never happen under the current regime.

That's why this Blog exists, and will continue to advocate for substantial change in Supply Management.




Thursday, December 12, 2013

#ChickenMafia Bedtime Story

Once upon a time, there was a lion, a zebra, and a vast plain of beautiful, lush grass.  The lion soon saw himself as the most powerful, and unilaterally claimed the title "King of the Beasts".  The zebra heard the lions proclamation, ignored it, and continued to eat the lush green grass.

The zebra fully understood the power of the lion's jaws and claws.  The zebra also had powerful jaws.  In addition, the zebra had a prehensile tongue that grabbed the lush green grass, and ripped off one mouthful after another.

The grass was no match for the strength of the zebra's teeth and tongue.

The lush green, nutritious grass helped the zebra grow strong and run fast.  The faster the zebra was able to run, the safer the zebra felt from the potential attack of the lion.

The beasts dropped their dung here, there, and everywhere on the grassy plain, fertilizing the grass.  The gentle rains came and watered the grass.

The grass grew plentifully, but some grasses were superior to others.  The zebra soon learned where the best grasses grew, and spent the majority of his time in those regions with better grass. The location of the zebras affected the location of the lions.   The better grass received a better share of dung of both zebra and lion.  The better grasses were thereby better fertilized, growing faster and better.

Eating the better grass, the zebra grew strong and multiplied.

The lion, in turn, chased and captured the slowest and weakest of the zebra, ensuring that the zebras with personal shortcomings were not propagated forward to the next generation.  The lion was fortified by the nutritious zebra meat, and the lion multiplied as well.  The weak and slow lions were not successful zebra hunters, were unable to have or support offspring, thereby ensuring that their weaknesses were not passed forward to the next generation.

An ecologically balanced world had formed, and all was good.

One day, the lion tried thinking a little too much.  The lion thought, that since he was the King of the Beasts, he was the most important part of the world, far more important than the zebra, and certainly more important than the grass which was walked on by both lions and zebras.

The lions called a meeting, and suggested to the zebras that what the world needed was more lions, and better fed lions.  If this was done, everybody would benefit, said the lions.

"How would the zebras benefit from more lions, and better fed lions?", asked the zebras.

The lions told the zebras that more lions would ensure that the zebras got lots of exercise running for their lives from the lions, and therefore the zebras would be fitter and healthier, and their offspring would improve that much faster.

The zebras weren't totally convinced by the lion's proposal.

One zebra spoke up, saying, "I think we need more zebras, not more lions.  I think we need more and better grass for the zebras to eat".

The lions started to laugh at what they thought was a silly zebra idea.

Nobody asked the grass what they thought.  Nobody asked the dung for their opinion.  Nobody thought to ask the rains for their ideas.  The grass was upset about being ignored.  The grass decided to show its sorrow by actions rather than words.

The grass held back its seeds, so new grass did not grow.  The grass grew very strong roots and stored its energy below ground.  The green shoots withered in the hot sun, and turned to dry, inedible, tasteless straw.

The zebras had a very difficult time finding enough food for themselves, so they migrated to far away, strange lands.  The lions were left alone with a dry dusty plain, with no zebras to eat.

The lions soon learned that all aspects of the circle of life were equally important.  The King of the Beasts isn't much of a king without his subjects, or without food for his subjects.

The lions apologized to the grass. The lions fertilized the grass. The rains came again, and the grass could no longer contain its vigor.  The grass grew lush and green again.  The zebra smelled the lush green grass from far away, and had soon returned.

This time, the rain, grass, dung, zebras, and lions lived as equals in harmony.  They realized that each was an important part of an eco-systemic feedback loop that worked through their mutual synergy.  No longer did one try to take advantage of the other.

The End

*   *   *

What is the moral of the story for #ChickenMafia?

I would suggest that things have gotten way out of balance.  It is more grass that can produce more zebras, which in turn permits more lions.  It is the small who permit the mighty.

#ChickenMafia rule as if they have the divine right of kings. There is little or no need to improve, for both the lousy and the excellent get the same minimum price, and have guaranteed customers.  Customers cannot choose their suppliers.  Over time, the #ChickenMafia have naturally grown fat and sloppy due to the dysfunctional system in which they live and benefit.

The #ChickenMafia's insists on recklessly gaining greater and greater wealth for themselves, to persecute the Small Flockers, and oppress and starve the citizens through 300% higher prices for chicken.  It is these things that has placed our chicken eco-system akilter, and dysfunctional.

It is time to re-balance the chicken lifecycle systems in our society.

The #ChickenMafia does not create wealth, nor feed the people. The #ChickenMafia creates a little wealth for a few who demand additional status and privilege, but in doing so, it destroys far greater wealth and rights of everybody else; a net negative to society.  The #ChickenMafia destroys our health with bogus chicken meat that is dangerous, toxic, disease-causing, and not sufficiently nutritious.

It is time to re-balance our chicken systems.

The following is a 6 minute TED talk by Mr. Nick Hanauer, a venture capitalist who was one of the first non-family investors in Amazon.com , a billionaire, and has a passion for exposing an invalid assumption in our society, similar to the #ChickenMafia 's assumption about their status and privilege.